Hög tid att slopa anonym kontroll av forskning

SOM BEKANT TILLÄMPAR vetenskapliga tidskrifter måna om sitt anseende numera det system för granskning av artiklar som heter peer review (här PR). Det innebär att en artikel granskas av i regel två utomstående forskare som uttalar sig om artikelns vetenskapliga värde, om den bör publiceras och i så fall om författaren först bör avkrävas förbättringar. […]

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