Hög tid att slopa anonym kontroll av forskning

SOM BEKANT TILLÄMPAR vetenskapliga tidskrifter måna om sitt anseende numera det system för granskning av artiklar som heter peer review (här PR). Det innebär att en artikel granskas av i regel två utomstående forskare som uttalar sig om artikelns vetenskapliga värde, om den bör publiceras och i så fall om författaren först bör avkrävas förbättringar. […]

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